And When She Was Good by Laura Lippman

Laura Lippman is a hugely famous author that, prior to this book, I had never heard of.  How does this happen?  She was even born in Atlanta, but grew up in Maryland.  That makes us practically cousins!  Turns out, she was a newspaper reporter before she turned author and I think that really shows in her writing style.  Did I mention she’s won nearly every award available to the mystery/crime/thriller novel genre?

And When She Was Good is a standalone novel featuring a suburban madam named Helen/Heloise.  Helen escapes her abusive father only to land in the hands of other not-so-nice men when she’s only a teenager.  To make ends meet, she becomes the darling escort to pimp, Val, where she becomes quite the professional prostitute.  Things get a bit shaky for Helen when she secretly helps the cops put Val behind bars for murder.  Thrust out into the world with very little money and no education, Helen transforms into Heloise and begins her own successful escort service in an upscale suburban neighborhood.  On top of an already risky business, Val acts as her silent partner from jail unaware that Heloise has given birth to their son.  Just when Heloise is getting comfy and a bit complacent, a neighboring suburban madam is found murdered.  Is Heloise next?

Lippman chooses the age-old dual narrative to tell Helen/Heloise’s story.  As we follow Heloise through her present day struggles and a sense of impending doom, every other chapter revisits her very unfortunate past as the sweet, smart Helen and focuses on how such a good girl could end up so far away from decency.  Normally, I’m not much for this narrative device, but Lippman’s obvious talent and ability help the two plots flow almost seamlessly throughout the novel.  And while I did tend to favor the Helen narrative, it never overshadowed the modern day story line.

What I loved most about And When She Was Good was being on the inside of the prostitution business.  So intriguing and page turning in and of itself.  The seedy underbelly of society is always so fascinating and I felt like Lippman had really done her research.  The details were superb and felt so true to life.  And despite such a typically shameful professional, Heloise and her girls aren’t the stereotypical prostitutes you come to expect.  They are hardworking women trying to support themselves with jobs that they are very good at.  Heloise runs her business strictly, professionally, and as safely as possible.  You come to respect her business savvy immensely.

A couple of things didn’t work so well for me.  First, I’m not sure what genre this novel fits into.  Don’t get me wrong, I’m not one for pigeon-holding anything into a neat and tidy box.  But I felt that this novel is being marketed as a mystery which is very misleading to me.  I guess there is a small mystery, but honestly, I knew who was behind everything from the get-go and I can’t imagine any other reader not figuring everything out early on either.  I’ve also seen the crime thriller catchphrase tossed around as well.  But again, I never felt on the edge of my seat.  To me,  And When She Was Good felt like a fictional memoir that highlighted the escort profession – the positives and the potential negatives.  And obviously, this blip is no fault of Lippman’s.

Lippman’s prose also threw me for a loop a couple times.  Sometimes she transitioned between characters or story sequences in one sentence rather abruptly.  I’d feel a bit lost and have to reread things over and over to figure out what had happened.  This issue could be entirely personal to my own  reading comprehension flaws, but it happened more than once throughout the book.  Just could have used some additional editing in my opinion, but nothing so bad that my reading experience was ruined.

I definitely recommend And When She Was Good to fans of Lippman and anyone else wanting to give her a try.  The plot is fascinating, the pacing page-turning, and the subject illuminating.  Great female characters that will challenge your preconceived notions and leave you with a strong sense of satisfaction when the last word is read.


About the Author:  Laura Lippman grew up in Baltimore and returned to her hometown in 1989 to work as a journalist. After writing seven books while still a full-time reporter, she left the Baltimore Sun to focus on fiction. The author of two New York Times bestsellers, What the Dead Knowand Another Thing to Fall, she has won numerous awards for her work, including the Edgar, Quill, Anthony, Nero Wolfe, Agatha, Gumshoe, Barry, and Macavity.

Thanks to TLC Book Tours and William Morrow for providing me with a free copy in exchange for my honest review! Don’t forget to check out the other blog stops here!


20 thoughts on “And When She Was Good by Laura Lippman

  1. Very nice review! I have read almost all of her standalone novels, and want to read this one desperately, especially given the book I just reviewed. I need to see the other side, if you know what I mean. I am glad that this book was such a good read for you and that it captured you in it’s details and back story. I will have to let you know what I think!

  2. I have read one book by Lippman (The Sugar House) and I wasn’t too impressed. This one sounds good and I really enjoyed reading your review. I always find it difficult when I expect a book to be in a particular genre and then it turns out to be quite different. Especially, like with this book, when you expect a thrilling read and it’s nothing like that. It’s a pity as it takes away from the enjoyment. It helps to have a (good) idea what genre a book is.

    • I’m trying to keep myself as spoiler free about books as possible these days – even in regards to genre – to keep these expectations from happening. It really isn’t the book’s fault or the author’s fault. I really did enjoy learning about the escort business, though, and think Lippman’s handling of everything was very well done. Some people might find the book suspenseful, but other than about 5 pages, nothing thrilled me in that way.

  3. I know I’ve heard of her before but can’t remember any titles in particular that she’s written. I do like historical stories about that profession if it’s not too gritty. Sometimes it seems inevitable that things will be horrific with prostitution story lines.

  4. I’m ready to compare the series with this stand alone as well. Gritty is a good adjective for this novel, I think, and it did have me on the edge of my seat. I read it quickly bc I couldn’t figure out how in the world Heloise was ever going to figure all of the mess that was her life out and still stay alive and become a productive member of society. I think it was the layers of lies that pulled me in and made it edgy for me. Great, balanced review!

    • I was definitely intrigued by how she was going to exit the business and if she even realistically could. I wonder if she ever found herself exposed several years later (you know, if she were real!)?

  5. Pingback: TLC Book Tour: And when she was good « Olduvai Reads

  6. Pingback: Laura Lippman, author of And When She Was Good, on tour August/September 2012 | TLC Book Tours

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s