Mansfield Park by Jane Austen

IMG_20130901_102915Mansfield Park was a book with baggage. Lots of bad baggage. I originally read the book after seeing the 1999 film with Johnny Lee Miller that I absolutely adored. Honestly, I can’t tell you how many times I watched that movie. Video Warehouse probably hated me with how torn and damaged their VHS copy was by the time I graduated and moved away. This was all before my Jane Austen obsession.

Even though I wasn’t quite the book fangirl I am now, I still wanted to read the source material. But Mansfield Park just wasn’t a book I should have attempted in high school. Obviously, I hated it and chucked it into a dusty corner to be forgotten. Until now!!!

Fourteen years have gone by and man, what fourteen years can do. I loved Mansfield Park this time around despite all of the anxiety and apprehension I felt going in. I’m also well aware that the 1999 film only borrowed bits and pieces from the novel and is in no way an adequate representation of Austen’s original story. And, for me, that’s okay. I still love the movie for what it is. Although I was a bit shocked at how sexualized everything was in the film…not that I should have been. Edmund is also far more appealing in the movie.

I read Mansfield Park over the course of four weeks. Slowly, but surely, I made my way through Austen’s most serious novel and mostly adored every word. I liked Fanny – her moral compass, although rigid, was respectable because she truly believed in her morality in the face of so many detractors. She fiercely defended her beliefs and didn’t back down for anyone. That’s far more than we can say about Edmund and his fickle morality in the face of Mary Crawford.

Sir Bertram is another father figure I’ve come to love (I know that Sir Bertram isn’t always the kind of character one can praise – specifically when you consider whether or not he was involved in the slave trade). Jane Austen can write some excellent fathers. Aunt Norris is a despicable bit of comic relief. I loved that Aunt Norris dotes on Maria while trashing Fanny which only manages to ruin Maria in the end.

As for Fanny and Edmund’s ending, holy rushed romance, Batman! Jeez. Edmund essentially just decides to be in love with Fanny and marry her in about two sentences. To me, this romance is underdeveloped and swept under the rug which tells me Austen’s point wasn’t to get Fanny a hero, but rather to let her be her own hero. I like that. I like Mansfield Park. For the moment, however fleeting, it shall stand as my favorite Austen. Until my next reread…

Rating: starstarstarstar

21 thoughts on “Mansfield Park by Jane Austen

  1. I agree with just about everything you wrote in this post! Except for the 1999 film, which I have not yet seen. I just finished reading MP less than 2 weeks ago and I loved it and Fanny Price, so it’s nice to see someone else share the same opinions 🙂 And your quote about Austen letting Fanny be her own hero…lovely!

  2. I agree about the ending. I did enjoy Mansfield Park too, I thought it was complex and elegantly written. And I found Fanny quite an interesting heroine – too bad I can’t really compare her with other Austen heroines yet, having read only two of her novels. Great review!

    • It will be interesting to see what you think about Fanny once you have more Austen heroines to compare her to. She quite different than the rest, but I love her for it!

  3. This is the Austen I am least excited about getting to – I have this & Persuasion left and whilst I am so looking forward to Persuasion, I haven’t built up much enthusiasm about Mansfield Park. My favourite Austen is Northanger Abbey, so I’m not into the serious so much!
    But your review has made me excited to try it 🙂

    • I understand your apprehension. I think Mansfield Park is most people’s least favorite. Fanny is such a unique Austen heroine that she really sheds a lot of light on Austen’s own beliefs. Definitely worth reading when you get a chance – but take your time – no need to rush!

  4. Pingback: Chawton Cottage: A glimpse into Jane Austen’s Life | Entdecke England

  5. Oooo your favorite Austen? That’s pretty high praise! This is the last Austen I have left to read, and I admit to being a bit apprehensive, but I’m planning to fit it in before the end of the year. I’m glad you liked it 🙂

  6. I keep putting Mansfield Park off, but perhaps after this review it is time to meet my demons head on. I don’t think it has helped that I have watched and loved the JLM adaptation either, I now want to rush off and watch it again.

    • Confront your demons! Mansfield Park is such a lovely book to use as a great comparison point for Austen’s other heroines. I just rewatched the JLM film and it was still wonderful!

  7. Pingback: The Classics Club: Wherein I Cave and Join… | The Blog of Litwits

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s